
The previous article in this series covered the increasing dominance of large companies and two countries (the U.S. and China) in advanced computing technology. In this article, we’ll see the related issues of proprietary control and national fragmentation.
The sudden emergence of GNU/Linux in the 1990s heralded the importance of free and open source software. But the Internet (which played a crucial role in the collaboration that powers Linux to this day) has simultaneously undermined free software by allowing vendors to run applications on their own systems, providing their customers with remote services that range from basic email to creative video editing.
The move of software applications into what is popularly called the „cloud“ has gone on for some 30 years and creates proprietary islands. Often, these SaaS vendors maintain complete control over critical data furnished by companies and individuals, and define the workflows that these companies and people use. The risks of giving companies that total control stand out especially when rogue, AI-driven procedures delete user accounts.
SaaS has obvious advantages over software installed on individual users‘ systems. It can be updated instantly if a bug or security flaw is found. There is no need for users to fuss with downloads and upgrades, and there is little risk of the software being incompatible with the user’s computer (especially now that browsers have standardized around powerful HTML5 features). Full disclosure: This article went to review using Google Docs, an admission of how appealing SaaS can be.
Software as a Service is now the default choice for most application vendors. It takes advantage of Internet connections so fast that a cloud application can respond as fast as the local computer—but only in areas that have top-notch Internet access. SaaS therefore exacerbates the digital divide while taking power away from the consumer. If the vendor decides that a feature interferes with its business model—the feature is gone, and tough luck for anyone that depended on it.
Many SaaS vendors use modern development techniques for pipelining changes to update the software multiple times a day. The public is not consulted; instead, A/B and bandit testing turn users into guinea pigs in countless experiments.
Open source (in healthy communities that aren’t dominated by a single company) is developed through open, public discussions. Although SaaS vendors claim to be giving users new features they’ll like, corporate goals always predominate.
If social media companies involved the public in feature development, the way open source projects do, it’s hard to imagine that the public would ask for addictive experiences that feed them disturbing claims of dubious accuracy. More likely, they seek „community, support and connection.“
Let’s indulge in a thought experiment. What if SaaS vendors discussed each change on public forums, like well-run open source projects? And instead of A/B testing, they could explicitly invite users to try new features and vote on what they like.
Such public involvement would slow down development, leading to fewer features over time—but that might be a good thing. Even if the companies didn’t allow full public discussion, they could bring together focus groups involving relevant users for each feature. This would lead to some push back against features that could cause harm.
No vendor is likely to implement one of these suggestions. But simply raising the issue allows open source advocates to point out the potential harms of SaaS and the ethical superiority of the free and open source software movements.
And open source is still needed to provide tools to people who live in regions without fast or continuously reliable Internet connections.
Although the Internet still functions as a universal connector, it is gradually pulling apart. China’s Great Firewall is well known, and in times of crisis—includng intermittently during the current war—Iran has cut off Internet access to its residents. Other countries have chokepoints on the Internet as well. But there are many less dramatic restrictions on Internet freedom in various countries.
This phenomenon was noticeable as early as 2001, and is not limited to authoritarian regimes: in 2001, for instance, France required Yahoo! to block access to Nazi-related sites in the U.S.
Now general technology is following the pattern of Internet restrictions. The U.S. has been trying to shut China off from semiconductors that are useful in artificial intelligence, while several countries are banning Huawei networking equipment because of fears that the Chinese government will exploit them. (Huawei is also scary competition when customers match their products against those of other companies.)
There’s now a U.S. artificial intelligence, a Chinese artificial intelligence, and a European artificial intelligence. Other nations must accept the crumbs from the rich countries‘ tables, although there are initiatives to create other regional strategies, such as in Africa.
The U.S. has banned imports of a wide range of advanced devices, most recently certain types of robots. Whenever governments restrict imports, they cite security or quality concerns, but the products are usually popular and highly competitive with local companies.
In its turn, China seems to be domesticating its chip industry, boosting local production while considering restrictions on both imports and exports.
In this environment, China’s recent announcement of a World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization (WAICO) is interesting. The agreement was signed, in addition to China by 28 countries who mostly are lagging in the development of AI, and is part of a global strategy by China. How much the alliance will reflect the actual interests of the other 28 countries remains to be seen.
Hong Feng, an evangelist for free and open source software, Lisp hacker, and system programmer in China, pointed out in his review of his article the irony of how AI has developed in the U.S. and China. The U.S. is a democratic country with a strong grass-roots tradition, but the major A.I. companies all run proprietary tools. In contrast, China, a highly controlled society, hosts companies such as DeepSeek and Kimi-K3 that produce open-source A.I. tools. He says that the Chinese developers are more alert to international needs and the benefits of producing tools for markets in other countries.
Hong thinks it’s good to have this variety of approaches; together the G2 countries (U.S. and China) will push AI forward. He also says that „the free market and a planned economy are not mutually exclusive.“ Although the golden age of American industry in the mid-20th century was a free market, the internal organization of the most successful firms (which range from General Motors to IBM) was highly planned.
There’s something beneficial about the current anxiety over various national controls over AI. The call for international justice and balance in AI highlights a debate that has been bubbling for some time.
Undeniably, computing has been dominated by U.S. businesses and technologies from its earliest days. Consider:
Like many unevenly distributed resources, those who benefit (U.S. residents) are often oblivious to the imbalance, but it is keenly resented by outsiders. Where U.S. dominance is diminishing, the alternatives are usually located in a single rival country, China. Free and open source software corrects the imbalance, and its creators must continue to promote an internationally fair ecosystem.
Free and open source software presents a continuing challenge to the tendencies that computing has toward central control. Current trends make it harder for both open source and the values it represents, but the trends also raise issues that demonstrate the importance of open source. While open source can’t always keep up, advocates can win over the public to its importance.
Sie sehen gerade einen Platzhalterinhalt von Vimeo. Um auf den eigentlichen Inhalt zuzugreifen, klicken Sie auf die Schaltfläche unten. Bitte beachten Sie, dass dabei Daten an Drittanbieter weitergegeben werden.
Mehr InformationenSie sehen gerade einen Platzhalterinhalt von YouTube. Um auf den eigentlichen Inhalt zuzugreifen, klicken Sie auf die Schaltfläche unten. Bitte beachten Sie, dass dabei Daten an Drittanbieter weitergegeben werden.
Mehr InformationenSie müssen den Inhalt von reCAPTCHA laden, um das Formular abzuschicken. Bitte beachten Sie, dass dabei Daten mit Drittanbietern ausgetauscht werden.
Mehr InformationenSie müssen den Inhalt von reCAPTCHA laden, um das Formular abzuschicken. Bitte beachten Sie, dass dabei Daten mit Drittanbietern ausgetauscht werden.
Mehr InformationenSie sehen gerade einen Platzhalterinhalt von reCAPTCHA. Um auf den eigentlichen Inhalt zuzugreifen, klicken Sie auf die Schaltfläche unten. Bitte beachten Sie, dass dabei Daten an Drittanbieter weitergegeben werden.
Mehr Informationen